County Legislators Want Offensive St. Patrick’s Day Merchandise Removed

Legislators ask businesses to stop displaying and selling defamatory items


Three Rockland County legislators objecting to offensive St. Patrick’s Day merchandise plan to introduce a resolution tonight asking local merchants to restrict their displays and sales. Their action follows a protest by members of the Ancient Order of Hiberians and Senator David Carlucci last Friday. 

Legislators Douglas Jobson, Patrick Moroney and Ilan Schoenberger want area businesses to stop selling and displaying St. Patrick’s Day items with derogatory or defamatory messages, which they said misrepresent Irish heritage and tradition. 

“We can not mandate the removal of the merchandise,” said Moroney. “We are calling upon these merchants to be considerate and respectful of the feelings and pride of those of Irish heritage.” 

The legislature passed a similar resolution last year, when offensive T-shirts, hats and novelty items were displayed. Although some merchants removed the offensive merchandise from display last year, similar items have reappeared recently.

Schoenberger said it is important for the legislature to make its position clear.

“We are informing merchants by resolution of the Legislature that we stand with the Irish-American community to state that it is inappropriate to display or sell items that are offensive in nature and hurtful to the Irish-Americans,” said Schoenberger.  

The resolution professes outrage for any act that misrepresents, ridicules or promotes hate and bias toward any religious, ethnic, racial or cultural groups. Jobson noted that Rockland County’s population is one of the most diverse in New York State.

“When one population is offended in a crude or offensive manner, we all must be offended,” said Jobson. “The annual St. Patrick’s Day Parade is one of the most anticipated events in the county and brings an immense sense of unity and pride to the thousands of Rocklanders that attend.  Items that demean and ridicule this anticipated event and the Irish culture are hurtful to the dedicated event organizers and to anyone, anywhere of Irish heritage.”

The legislature meets Tuesday with Rockland County Executive C. Scott Vanderhoef delivering the 2013 State of the County address at 7 p.m. 

The 51st annual St. Patrick’s Day Parade in Pearl River kicks off at 1:30 p.m. on Sunday, March 17.

NoName March 06, 2013 at 10:34 AM
Now for all of you who say "laugh it off, We dont care, No big deal. Dont they have better things to fight for?" Now I am paraphrasing as it was said in the Movie "A Time for a Kill", "Close your eyes and imagine the disgusting slogans on the merchandise targeted, blacks, gays, hispanics, or Jewish people," The outrage would be immense and please dont even pretend for a minute that it wouldnt be.
Richie Himes March 06, 2013 at 11:23 AM
I understand your point but in this case, the people complaining are largely responsible for promoting the stereotype.
Andromachos March 06, 2013 at 01:28 PM
As a self-important bureaucrat with no sense of humor I demand that no one have a sense of humor.
what is mid boggling..is that a local yokel...who was elected chose to stand in a supermarket parking lot...causing shoppers to have to avoid gettinginto an accident..due to the extraneous protesters..a question"Why didnt they protest in the malls parking lot??wher they scared???afraid???but for any elected offical to advise his constituents to boycott a whole mall is beyond....one dollar less tax revenue is some poor souls lunch maybe or dinner that the state pays for!!!!!!!maybe hibernation is the solution !!!!!!!!!!let the taxpayers be spared for like 6 months a year without seeing them!!!!!downside the poor bears!!!!!!!
Smitty Chesterfield March 06, 2013 at 01:54 PM
Richie hit the nail on the head. its not groups of indians or russians or asians primarily wearing the shirts and drinking till they puke, right? many that i;ve seen over the years have pale skin and freckles lol


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »